Chipping in for the house is not the same as lending your roommate money
Updated: 2 hours ago
Two roommates buy a house. One puts $40,000 toward the down payment. The other lends her roommate $5,000 for his share of the furniture, due back by June, with a little interest. Same household, same month, two different deals. The first roommate now owns part of the house. The second owns nothing in the house. She owns a right to be paid back.
Money an owner puts into a company works the same way. It goes in as a capital contribution or as a loan. Most owners never decide which, and the decision gets made for them later by an accountant, the IRS, a court, or a co-owner with a different memory. I covered the mechanics in an earlier post. This is the plain-English version.
A Contribution Buys Into the House
A capital contribution is chipping in for the house. You get ownership, or more of it, in return. There is no payback date. You get money back the way any owner does: through distributions when the company can afford them, or when you sell or the company winds down. If the business loses value, your stake loses value with it.
For tax purposes, a contribution adds to your basis in your LLC interest or your shares. Basis is roughly your tax investment in the company. It caps the losses you can deduct and decides how much of what you take out later comes back tax-free.
A Loan Comes With a Payback Date
A loan is lending your roommate money. You own no more of the company than before. The company owes you a fixed amount on fixed terms, good year or bad. Repayment of principal isn't taxable to you. The interest is income to you and generally deductible by the company.
The real difference shows up when the company winds down. Creditors get paid before owners get anything back, and under most state LLC statutes an owner who lent money stands in line with the other creditors, to the extent the law allows. An owner who contributed waits at the back with the other owners. A documented loan can be the difference between recovering something and recovering nothing.
Two caveats. In bankruptcy, a court can push an insider's loan behind outside creditors or treat it as equity outright. And a loan is unsecured unless you take a security interest. My post on member liens covers what a lien protects and what it doesn't.
How a Loan Gets Turned Into a Contribution
Calling something a loan doesn't make it one. The IRS and the courts look at substance, and owner loans get extra scrutiny because nobody negotiated across the table. Courts weigh many factors, but these sink most owner loans:
No promissory note
No interest, or interest below the applicable federal rate (AFR), the minimum rate the IRS publishes each month
No repayment schedule, or a schedule nobody follows
No payments, ever
No security, and terms no outside lender would accept
Strip those away and your loan looks like a contribution with a hopeful label. The company loses its interest deductions. Repayments you treated as tax-free return of principal can become distributions, and in a C corporation, taxable dividends. A below-market loan can also trigger imputed interest, where the IRS taxes interest nobody paid.
It cuts the other way too. An owner who meant to buy more ownership but booked the money as a loan can face a co-owner insisting the money bought no ownership at all.
Document It When the Money Moves
The fix costs almost nothing at the time and a lot to rebuild later.
For a contribution. Record it in the capital accounts or the stock ledger. If ownership percentages change, update the ownership schedule, and get your co-owners' written consent.
For a loan. A signed promissory note with interest at or above the AFR and a repayment schedule. If you want priority over unsecured creditors, add a security agreement and file a financing statement. Then make the payments on time.
For both. A written consent or resolution approving the transaction, and bank records that match it.
The S Corporation Wrinkle
S corporation shareholders can deduct the company's losses only up to their basis, and they have two kinds: stock basis and debt basis. Debt basis comes only from a bona fide loan running directly from you to the corporation. Personally guaranteeing the company's bank loan doesn't create it. Paying on that guarantee does, to the extent you pay. And if losses have drawn your debt basis down, repayment of the loan can be partly taxable to you. In an S corporation, sloppy loan paperwork can cost you the deductions you were counting on.
Where the Analogy Breaks
Roommates can settle a $5,000 loan over dinner. Your company is a separate legal person, and its co-owners, its creditors, and the IRS each get a say in what the money was. The roommate version also skips the in-between tools, such as convertible notes and preferred interests, that a company can use when neither label fits.
Where I Come In
I look at how money has moved between you and the company, and tell you what each transfer is on paper.
Structure Review, from $750. I look at how money has gone into the company, how it was recorded, and where the records and the reality don't match.
Document Review, from $650. I review your operating agreement, bylaws, shareholders' agreement, or existing notes for how they treat contributions, loans, and repayment, and flag the gaps.
Document Review & Revision, from $1,400. The review plus revised language. Where a revision turns on the company law of a state where I'm not licensed, you engage an attorney licensed there to advise on that question, and I build their advice into the document.
Not sure which fits? A Structuring Consultation is $200, and the fee is credited in full toward any written work you commission within 30 days.
More free guides and checklists are on the Free Resources page.
Part 8 of 10: Business Terms, Explained Like a Person. If you're the one who opens the oven door before the timer goes off, the whole series is already up.
