top of page

Reasonable compensation: pay the cook before you pay the owner

Writer: Brandi Joffrion
Brandi Joffrion
Nov 2
4 min read

Updated: 2 hours ago

Picture a diner owned by the person who works the grill every shift. Two jobs are happening at once: the cook, who earns a wage, and the owner, who keeps whatever profit is left. If that owner hired someone else to run the grill, she would pay a market wage before counting a dime of profit. The IRS expects an S corporation owner to do the same for herself. Pay the cook first, then pay the owner.


That is reasonable compensation. My earlier post goes deeper on the case law. This is the plain-English version.


Why the Rule Exists


An S corporation passes its profit through to its shareholders' returns. Wages paid to a shareholder-employee carry Social Security and Medicare taxes, withheld and matched through payroll. Distributions don't. Compare a sole proprietor or a single-member LLC owner, who pays self-employment tax on the business's whole net profit.


That gap is the main appeal of the S election, and it's why the rule exists. Without it, every owner would pay herself nothing in wages, take everything as distributions, and skip payroll tax entirely. The IRS's position, backed by decades of cases, is that an S corporation must pay a shareholder-employee reasonable compensation for services before making non-wage distributions.


Who It Applies To


The rule reaches shareholders who work for the corporation. Under the payroll tax regulations, a corporate officer is an employee unless the officer performs only minor services and receives no pay for them, directly or indirectly. If you run the company, sell for it, or do the work it sells, your services aren't minor. A purely passive shareholder who does no work isn't in the cook's seat.


The rule applies the same way to an LLC that has elected S corporation status. The election changes the tax rules, not the company's state-law form, and it brings the payroll obligation with it.


What the IRS Looks At


There is no formula. The question is what the company would have to pay someone else to do what you do. The factors the IRS lists include:


  • Your training and experience

  • Your duties and responsibilities

  • The time and effort you devote to the business

  • What comparable businesses pay for similar services

  • What the company pays its non-owner employees

  • The company's dividend and distribution history

  • How and when bonuses go to key people

  • Compensation agreements, and any formula used to set pay


The IRS's internal guide for its valuation staff also weighs the company's size, complexity, and financial condition, including whether it could afford reasonable salaries in the years in question. Where the money comes from matters too. Profit your own work generates points toward wages. Profit from other employees' work, from equipment, or from capital can more fairly come out as distributions.


The rule bites hardest when money comes out. An owner taking large distributions alongside a token salary is the classic target.


What Happens If You Get It Wrong


The IRS can recharacterize distributions as wages. That brings back the payroll taxes you skipped, both the employer and employee shares of Social Security and Medicare plus federal unemployment tax, along with interest and penalties for failing to deposit and report them. Courts have upheld these reclassifications repeatedly, including against owners who paid themselves nothing at all and owners who paid themselves a token salary.


The Common Mistakes


  • Zero salary. The most common mistake and the easiest to spot: the return shows distributions and no officer compensation.

  • A rule-of-thumb percentage. Splits like 60/40 circulate online. None comes from the IRS, and none answers the real question: what would it cost to fill your job?

  • Setting salary in December. A number picked at year-end from whatever is left reads as an afterthought. Pay set in advance and run through regular payroll reads as a wage.

  • Never revisiting the number. Your role and the market change. Your salary should keep pace.

  • Ignoring the trade-off. A defensible salary shrinks the payroll tax savings that justified the election. If the salary your role supports eats most of the profit, the S election may not earn its added cost.


Where the Analogy Breaks


A real cook's wage is set by the market. Yours is set by you, which is the whole problem the rule addresses. Most owners also hold more than one job: cook, bookkeeper, and sales team. Reasonable compensation reflects all of it, weighted by the time you spend on each. And in a C corporation the fight runs the other way. Salary is deductible and dividends aren't, so the IRS challenges owner pay as too high.


Where I Come In


I look at how you pay yourself, and tell you whether the S election still earns its keep.


  • Entity Tax Classification Analysis, from $850. Whether your S election still makes sense once a defensible salary is part of the math, compared with the other classifications open to you.

  • Structure Review, from $750. How your entities, ownership, and money flows fit together, including how the owners are being paid.

  • Restructuring Tax Analysis, from $1,500. If the answer is a change in tax status or structure, the tax consequences of getting there.


Not sure which fits? A Structuring Consultation is $200, and the fee is credited in full toward any written work you commission within 30 days.


More free guides and checklists are on the Free Resources page.


Part 9 of 10: Business Terms, Explained Like a Person. If you're the reader who flips to the last page of the mystery first, the whole series is already up.

Recent Posts

See All
A residency audit readiness checklist

If you split your year between states, the state you left may say you never left. The records to keep, the ties to move, and the traps to avoid.

 
 
Your LLC isn't in your trust

A revocable trust controls only what it owns. If your LLC interest is still in your name, your trust doesn't reach your business.

 
 

Plain-English answers, no invoice attached.  Every Tuesday and Wednesday on LinkedIn.

​

  • LinkedIn
bottom of page