top of page

Vesting is earning your keys, and the 83(b) election locks in today's price

Writer: Brandi Joffrion
Brandi Joffrion
Nov 2
5 min read

Updated: 2 hours ago

Picture buying a house with two friends. Everyone gets a key on day one. But the deal says you earn your share over four years, and if you move out early, the others can buy back the share you haven't earned yet, usually at what you paid for it.


That's vesting. The 83(b) election is the tax side: a 30-day window to pay tax on your share at today's price instead of at whatever it's worth each time a piece becomes yours.


Why Founders Should Want Vesting


Without vesting, a co-founder who leaves after six months keeps their whole stake. The founders still doing the work carry a passive owner for the life of the company, and future investors notice.


Vesting replaces that fight with a formula. Each founder owns their shares or units from day one, but the company or the other owners can repurchase the unvested portion if a founder leaves. It protects the founders who stay, and it protects the one who leaves, because everyone knows in advance what each person keeps.


Cliffs and Acceleration


Two terms do most of the work.


The cliff. A common schedule runs four years with a one-year cliff: nothing vests in the first year, a quarter vests at the one-year mark, and the rest vests monthly or quarterly after that. The cliff keeps someone who leaves in month five from walking away with anything. Those numbers are convention, not law. Pick the ones that fit your company.


Acceleration. Some or all unvested equity vests early when a specified event happens. Single-trigger acceleration vests on one event, usually a sale of the company. Double-trigger requires two: a sale, and then the founder being let go without cause within a set period after it. Buyers tend to prefer double-trigger, because they want the founders to stay.


The 83(b) Election


Here's the tax problem vesting creates. Under section 83 of the Internal Revenue Code, property you receive for services isn't taxed while you can still forfeit it. Instead, each piece is taxed as ordinary income when it vests, at its value on that date, minus anything you paid. If the company grows, each slice is taxed at a higher value, and you owe the tax with no cash in hand to pay it.


An 83(b) election reverses that. You elect to be taxed on the value at the grant date instead, when founder equity is usually worth very little. If you paid full value for the shares, the income is zero. Later growth isn't taxed when the shares vest. It's taxed as capital gain when you sell, and your holding period starts at the grant.


There are counterpoints:


  • If you forfeit, you don't get the tax back. Leave before vesting, the company repurchases your unvested shares, and the tax you paid on them is gone. Generally the most you can deduct is what you paid for the shares, less anything you got back for them.

  • It isn't always cheap. If the equity has real value at grant, the election means paying tax now on value you may never realize.

  • It's irrevocable. The IRS consents to revoking it only in narrow cases, such as a mistake of fact.


For most founders taking equity at formation, filing still makes sense. But it's a decision, not a reflex.


The 30-Day Window


The deadline is 30 days after the date the property is transferred to you. Not 30 days after someone gets around to the paperwork, and not at tax time. There are no extensions and no late elections. Miss it, and the default rule applies for good.


You have two ways to file. The IRS now has Form 15620, Section 83(b) Election, which you can complete through your IRS online account and either submit electronically or download, sign, and mail to the IRS service center where you file your return. You can also still mail a signed written statement containing the required information. Use one method, not both. If you mail, send it certified with a return receipt so you can prove the date.


Either way, give a copy to the company and keep one yourself. You'll want it when investors or a buyer ask.


Profits Interests in LLCs


LLCs often grant founders and key people a profits interest: a share of future growth and profits, with no share of the value the company has today. Under IRS guidance, a profits interest that meets certain conditions isn't taxed when it's granted or when it vests, and the guidance says no 83(b) election is required.


Many practitioners file one anyway, as a protective election. The safe harbor has conditions, and if an interest falls outside them, a timely protective 83(b) keeps the vesting-date rule from applying. It costs little, and it can't be filed late. Talk to your tax adviser before the 30 days run.


Where the Terms Live


Vesting has to be written down somewhere, and where depends on timing.


Before the company exists, founders can sign a founders' agreement that sets the split, the vesting schedule, the cliff, acceleration, and what happens if someone leaves, to be carried into the company's documents once it's formed. That's an agreement between separate people, and it's the cleanest time to have the conversation.


After formation, the terms belong in the company's own documents: a stock restriction or restricted stock purchase agreement for a corporation, or the operating agreement and grant documents for an LLC. Co-founder equity: vesting, 83(b), and what happens when a founder leaves covers the exit side, and Buying out a member: what actually has to happen covers the mechanics.


Where I Come In


I put the founders' split and vesting terms in writing, and check that the tax side matches the deal.


  • Owners' Agreement, from $1,850. For founders before they form: the split, vesting, cliff, acceleration, and departure terms, agreed while everyone still agrees.

  • Document Review & Revision, from $1,400. For a company that already exists: a review of the operating agreement or stock restriction agreement, plus revised vesting and repurchase language. Where a revision turns on the company law of a state where I'm not licensed, you engage an attorney licensed there to advise on that question, and I build their advice into the document.

  • Entity Tax Classification Analysis, from $850. How your company is taxed, and what that means for granting stock, units, or profits interests to founders.


Not sure which fits? A Structuring Consultation is $200, and the fee is credited in full toward any written work you commission within 30 days.


More free guides and checklists are on the Free Resources page.


Part 7 of 10: Business Terms, Explained Like a Person. If you were the kid who shook every birthday present before the party, the whole series is already up.

Recent Posts

See All
A residency audit readiness checklist

If you split your year between states, the state you left may say you never left. The records to keep, the ties to move, and the traps to avoid.

 
 
Your LLC isn't in your trust

A revocable trust controls only what it owns. If your LLC interest is still in your name, your trust doesn't reach your business.

 
 

Plain-English answers, no invoice attached.  Every Tuesday and Wednesday on LinkedIn.

​

  • LinkedIn
bottom of page